Final night time, former President Donald Trump returned to X, the social media web site as soon as referred to as Twitter in as bombastic a type as potential: a livestream with the positioning’s now-owner Elon Musk. The interview on Areas, X’s platform for dwell audio conversations, lined all the pieces from unlawful immigration to union busting. At one level, Trump and Musk underscored the necessity for an American chief who would encourage concern in different nations. Over the course of two hours, the richest man on the planet and the previous president of america reminded us that they share some hanging similarities — large egos, a love of consideration and social media, but on the similar time a way of victimhood. (Vice President Kamala Harris would possibly love Venn diagrams, however she’d should hate this intersection.)
Whereas Trump had been banned following the occasions of January 6, and reinstated when Musk took over, he solely returned to the platform in textual content for yesterday’s dialog. Each Musk and Trump promoted the interview as a marquee leisure occasion, with Musk promising that it could be “unscripted with no limits on subject material, so ought to be extremely entertaining!” But the 2 males gabbed largely in regards to the predictable subjects: the US border, crime, after which nonetheless extra in regards to the border. The interview was yet one more alternative for Trump to spew insults and make false statements, with no pushback from his interviewer — not even when Trump advised Musk, the CEO of an EV firm, that he deliberate to “drill, child, drill” in his second time period.
The livestream began almost an hour late as a consequence of technical difficulties. Nearly 20 minutes after it was set to start, Musk wrote that there gave the impression to be a “huge DDOS assault on X.” (A DDoS assault deliberately disrupts a web site by flooding it with visitors; it wouldn’t be correct to name it a DDoS assault if lots of people organically needed to tune in.) Earlier Areas occasions on X have been rife with glitches, too — a dwell convo between Musk and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis final Could, during which DeSantis introduced his presidential bid, crashed when over 500,000 folks tried to pay attention in. Earlier than the Trump interview, Musk mentioned that X could be conducting stress assessments to make sure the livestream might deal with the visitors. High livestreams on YouTube and Twitch have dealt with thousands and thousands of concurrent viewers earlier than, and the most well-liked streamers on these platforms usually take pleasure in lots of of 1000’s of viewers.
At this time, Trump returned to Fact Social, the social media web site that he has a majority stake in, to reward Musk and lash out towards the media for reporting on the technical points that delayed the livestream.
“I completely HATE the Pretend Information Media,” he wrote. “So dangerous for our Nation!”
Trump and Musk’s rocky historical past
Trump and Musk haven’t all the time been on good phrases. Within the run-up to the presidential election in 2016, Musk mentioned in a CNBC interview that Trump was “not the correct man,” noting that he didn’t have the “form of character that displays nicely on america.” Nonetheless, as soon as Trump was in workplace Musk initially fostered a pleasant relationship with the president, even agreeing to hitch two White Home advisory councils. He rapidly stepped down after Trump pulled out of the Paris Settlement, which goals to restrict international warming to below 2 levels Celsius.
Then, at a rally in 2022, Trump claimed that Musk had advised him he voted for him in 2016, calling the billionaire a “bullshit artist.” Musk sniped again that Trump ought to “sail into the sundown,” and in response Trump wrote on Fact Social that Musk had come to the Oval Workplace to ask for assist “on all of his many backed tasks,” and that he might have advised Musk to drop to his knees and beg.
A truth examine on Trump and Musk on immigration
One matter the 2 males regularly returned to was immigration, and the insistence that there’s a scourge of crime dedicated by undocumented immigrants sweeping the nation. Trump mentioned that over 20 million folks have illegally crossed the US border below President Joe Biden, far outpacing estimates from specialists. He repeated the unsubstantiated declare that lots of them have been coming from jails and psychological establishments and referred to as them “stone chilly killers in lots of instances.”
Trump and Musk additionally agreed that migrant crime was “destroying” cities like New York and San Francisco. “They only let violent criminals out in New York,” mentioned Musk. “The one one they’re going to prosecute is Donald Trump,” the previous president interjected. In reality, violent crime in US cities has plummeted within the first half of 2024.
All that seems to be water below the bridge now. Musk formally endorsed Trump in July on the day of his tried assassination, and is backing a tremendous PAC aiming to get 800,000 Individuals in swing states to vote for Trump. The Wall Road Journal not too long ago reported that the 2 communicate on the telephone a number of instances a month now to debate subjects reminiscent of “immigration, know-how and science.”
Why the 2 see eye to eye
Because the dialog wound down, Trump congratulated Musk on getting “60 to 70 million” listeners, showing to mistake the variety of passive views the occasion acquired on X with the quantity of people that had tuned in (just a little over 1 million). Musk mused that the entire variety of views the interview would ultimately get could be within the lots of of thousands and thousands.
It was a second that summed up what the 2 males have in frequent — a bent to self-aggrandize and inflate their accomplishments. They each have a behavior of claiming incendiary issues, whether or not on digital camera or on-line, and have used social media to develop a fervent fan base round their cult of persona.
Trump has been largely absent on X even after being reinstated in November 2022, posting totally on Fact Social. He’s below an exclusivity clause that limits non-political posts he could make exterior of Fact Social — however this interview seems to fall below an exemption as a result of it’s associated to politics. Yesterday, within the lead-up to the interview, Trump made a number of posts on X boosting his presidential marketing campaign, pinning a marketing campaign advert to the highest of his profile.
Are you higher off now than you have been after I was president?
Our economic system is shattered. Our border has been erased. We’re a nation in decline.
Make the American Dream AFFORDABLE once more. Make America SAFE once more. Make America GREAT Once more!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) August 12, 2024
Previous to August 12, Trump hadn’t posted on X in nearly a yr.
Now, although, Musk and Trump are additionally united by a way of non-public grievance and persecution. Trump complained that the Democrats had weaponized the authorized system towards him, referring to the numerous legal investigations he’s below. “The Biden administration did one thing that’s by no means been achieved on this nation, and that’s go after their political opponent — me — with this nonsense,” Trump mentioned. A number of days in the past, Musk posted a graphic (the supply of which is unclear) on X portraying himself and his political beliefs because the aspect resisting oppression — very like Luke Skywalker in Star Wars, Katniss Everdeen in The Starvation Video games, or Neo in The Matrix. “When it’s fiction you perceive,” the image reads. “You refuse to see it when it’s the fact you’re dwelling in.”
Musk groused that individuals painted him as a “far-right man, which is absurd as a result of I’m, like, making electrical autos,” he mentioned. “I stood in line for six hours to shake Obama’s hand when he was president.” Whereas Musk mentioned he used to vote for Democrats, in 2022 he introduced he would begin voting Republican as a result of the Dems had develop into the social gathering of “division & hate.” Up to now yr he has repeated rhetoric echoing the white supremacist “nice alternative” principle, which alleges that there’s a conspiracy to interchange white folks by bringing undocumented immigrants into the US. He has additionally persistently been dismissive of LGBTQ+ equality, displaying explicit contempt for transgender folks. Musk’s daughter, who’s trans, has criticized his therapy of her gender identification on Instagram’s Threads.
A truth examine on Trump and Musk on inflation
Turning to the economic system, each males blamed extra authorities spending throughout the pandemic as the first reason behind inflation. Economists usually attribute latest US inflation to a mixture of causes — not simply authorities spending, but in addition provide chain interruptions mixed with a surge in client demand. The $2.2 trillion CARES Act, one of many main Covid-19 stimulus packages, was signed into regulation by Trump.
There have been loads of unusual asides that the 2 males touched on throughout the dialog on X, highlighting their shared chaos — reminiscent of when Musk introduced up constructing tunnels to “clear up visitors.” Trump praised China’s high-speed rail system, however Musk was referring to tunnels for Tesla automobiles, just like the Las Vegas Loop. Each agreed that Harris was a “far left” politician, with Trump repeating his accusation that Biden’s choice to drop out of the presidential race was a “coup” performed by the Democratic Celebration. Whereas with regards to authorities overspending, Trump declared that he would shutter the Division of Training and “transfer schooling again to the states” throughout his second time period. The previous president additionally appeared to reward Musk for his mass firing of disgruntled Twitter staff in late 2022. “I received’t point out the identify of the corporate,” he mentioned, “however they go on strike and also you say, ‘That’s okay, you’re all gone.’” After the X interview, the United Auto Employees filed federal labor prices with the Nationwide Labor Relations Board, accusing Trump and Musk of “unlawful makes an attempt to threaten and intimidate staff.”
On the high of the interview, Musk mentioned that he needed to indicate what Trump was like exterior of an adversarial interview, although the previous president is legendary for holding numerous rallies the place he speaks with out restraint. “It’s exhausting to catch a vibe about somebody in the event you simply don’t hear them discuss in a standard means,” Musk claimed, including that the occasion was geared toward “open-minded impartial voters.” It stays to be seen what number of voters have been impressed by Trump’s and Musk’s vibes.

